Study |
Population |
Age (in years) |
Race/ethnicity |
Time of assessment |
Measures |
Findings |
Limitations |
Almeria et al. (2020) |
35 patients without a history of prior cognitive impairment, psychiatric illness, or other CNS disease Barcelona, Spain 45.7% male |
M=47.6 SD=8.9 Range=24-60 |
Not listed |
10–35 days post discharge from hospital |
TAVEC: list learning, interference, recognition WMS-IV: Visual reproduction Digit Span Letters and Numbers TMT SDMT Stroop Verbal fluency BNT HADS |
34.3% of the patients reported cognitive complaints No differences in neuropsychological performance between patients who reported cognitive complaints compared to those who did not endorse cognitive complaints Higher levels of anxiety and depression were found among individuals who endorsed cognitive complaints Neurological symptoms such as headache as well as loss of smell and taste were strongly associated with impaired attention, memory, and executive function |
Small sample size Older individuals were excluded to avoid age-related cognitive impairment. Assessed shortly after discharge home Some data was extracted from the EMR rather than being assessed directly |
Bellan et al. (2021) |
238 previously hospitalized patients Italy 59.7% male |
Median=61 Range=50-71 |
Not listed |
3–4 months post discharge from hospital |
IES-R |
Most patients did not endorse posttraumatic stress: 57.1% were within normal range, 25.6% reported mild symptoms, 11.3% reported moderate, and 5.9% reported severe symptoms Male sex was the only factor independently associated with the presence of moderate to severe PTS symptoms |
Only contacted patients who necessitated inpatient hospitalization High rate of patients declining participation Evaluation was limited to assessment of posttraumatic stress |
Bonazza et al. (2020) |
261 previously hospitalized patients (35.2% received intensive care) Italy 68.2% male |
M=58.9 SD=13.3 |
Not listed |
2 months post discharge from hospital |
HADS IES-R |
High prevalence of patients reported anxiety (28%), depression (16%), as well as posttraumatic stress (36.4%) Psychological distress was associated with female gender. Younger patients are more likely to have anxiety No correlations were found between duration of hospitalization or the intensity of care, and psychological outcomes |
Participants assessed within quarantine setting Underlying reasons for high endorsement of PTS remains unclear |
Bowles et al. (2020) |
1409 hospitalized patients New York, US 51% male |
M=67 SD=15 |
27% White; 28% Black; 35% Hispanic; 9% other |
Not listed |
OASIS-D1 mandatory assessment tool |
Improvements in cognitive functioning and anxiety usually within one month post hospital discharge 16% increase in cognitive functioning and 35% decrease in anxiety |
Information on rehospitalization and death after hospital discharge was not available |
Cai et al. (2020) |
126 hospitalized patients Shenzhen, China 47.6% male |
M=45.7 SD=14 |
Not listed |
Not listed |
Self-report of PTSD Self-report of depression Self-report of anxiety |
54% reported psychiatric distress Comorbidity of clinically significant stress response, anxiety and depression was 11.9% 31% had clinically significant stress response; 22.2% had clinical anxiety; 38.1% had clinical depression Older survivors (over age 60) reported lower levels of stress response than younger individuals Significantly higher rates of psychiatric symptoms than seen following previous major disasters |
23 participants had prior history of psychiatric illness All patients were discharged from hospital into a mandatory quarantine facility, and were assessed while in quarantine |
Daher et al. (2020) |
33 hospitalized patients not requiring mechanical ventilation Germany 67% male |
M=64 SD=3 |
Not listed |
6 weeks post discharge from hospital |
EQ-5D-5L PHQ-9 GAD-7 |
Most common endorsement was mild depression and anxiety On quality-of-life measures, patients reported slight to moderate difficulties with mobility, self-care, completing ADLs as well as elevated levels of pain/discomfort and anxiety/depression |
Patients had multiple medical comorbidities, and did not identify premorbid psychiatric disorders Primary outcome was respiratory function; assessment of psychiatric concerns was secondary aim |
de Graaf et al. (2021) |
81 hospitalized patients (42% requiring ICU admission); only 59 completed psychological assessments Netherlands 51% male |
M=60.8 SD=13 Range=27-88 |
Not listed |
6 weeks post discharge from hospital |
GAD-7 PHQ-9 PCL-5 Cognitive Failures Questionnaire IQ Code-N semi structured clinical interview |
17% reported elevated symptoms of depression; 5% endorsed elevated anxiety; 10% met criteria for PTSD 40% reported previous mental health treatment 25% of patients endorsed cognitive impairments |
Small Sample size Less than 50% of sample were admitted to the hospital participated in the study Lack of baseline data |
De Lorenzo et al. (2020) |
185 patients (68.1% requiring inpatient hospitalization) Italy 66.5% male |
M=57 Range=48-67 |
90.8% European; 8.6% Hispanic; 0.5% African-American |
Median of 23 days post discharge from hospital |
WHOQOL-BREF IES-R STAI-Y WHIIRS Unstructured clinical interview |
Cognitive impairment was observed in 25% of patients despite no history of cognitive disorder 22.2% of patients met criteria for PTSD |
Lack of objective assessment of cognition Use of unstructured clinical interviews Only previously hospitalized patients were recruited |
Garrigues et al. (2020) |
129 hospitalized patients France 75% male |
M=63.2 SD=15.7 |
Not listed |
Mean of 110.8 (SD=11.1) days post admission |
EQ-5D-5L Brief phone interview of clinical symptoms |
Most patients reported persistent symptoms of fatigue (55%), memory loss (34%) concentration difficulties (24%), and sleep disorders (30.8%) |
Exclusive use of self-reported measures Lack of baseline functioning Only previously hospitalized patients were recruited |
Guo et al. (2020) |
259 patients China 46.9% male |
<18=1.6% 18–46=53.1% 46–49=43.3% >69=2% |
Not listed |
One month post discharge from hospital |
SF-36 |
Role limitations due to emotional problems were related to male sex and positive nucleic acid duration Significant differences were found in vitality and mental health of patients aged 46–69 with positive nucleic acid duration longer than 14 days |
High rate of attrition across follow-up period Lack of standardized, granular mental assessment Only previously hospitalized patients were recruited |
Huang et al. (2021) |
1733 patients China 52% male |
M=57 |
Not listed |
Median of 184 (Range=175–199) days after symptom onset |
mMRC EQ-5D-5L EQ-VAS |
23% of reported depression or anxiety 63% reported fatigue/muscle weakness 25% reported sleep difficulties |
Lack of baseline functioning Exclusion of patients with mild symptoms |
Islam et al. (2021) |
1002 patients (21% were previously hospitalized) Bangladesh 57.9% male |
M=34.7 SD=13.9 Range=18-81 |
Bangladeshi |
Not listed |
PHQ-9 Self-report treatment history Assessment of fear of reinfection |
30.4% endorsed minimal symptoms of depression, 21.5% endorsed mild symptoms, 24.2% endorsed moderate symptoms, 19.4% endorsed moderate-severe symptoms, 4.6% endorsed severe symptoms 52.2% reported sleep disturbance Lower SES, poor health, sleep disturbance, asthma/respiratory problems, and fear of reinfection were associated with moderate-severe depression |
Time of assessment was not provided Diagnostic status determined by self-report rather than utilization of PCR test |
Janiri et al. (2020) |
61 patients who were referred to postacute care clinic (9% previously required ICU admission) Italy 59% male |
>60 |
Italian |
Mean of 41 days (SD=19) post discharge from hospital |
TEMPS-A-39 Difficulties in Emotion Regulation Scale Kessler Questionnaire-10 |
High likelihood of psychological distress was associated with female gender, Cyclothymic and Depressive scales of TEMPS, self-reported impulse control difficulties and lack of emotional clarity scales of DERS |
Small sample size Statistical models in (ANCOVA with 7 covariates) in light of sample size |
Jeong et al. (2020) |
234 patients who were admitted to nonhospital facilities for isolation and monitoring (28.2% were asymptomatic and 71.8% were mildly symptomatic) South Korea 39.7% male |
M=37.78 SD=15.57 |
South Korean |
Not listed |
HADS |
During first week of quarantine, 19.8% endorsed mild depression or anxiety symptoms At 1 week follow-up, 14% reported depression or anxiety symptoms; significant decline in anxiety but not depression 20% of the asymptomatic group endorsed mood difficulties Anxiety and depression levels positively associated with quarantine durations |
Small sample size Clinical outcomes of all the patients were not included Mental health data was collected via mobile-phone based survey. Patients without access was contacted by physicians via direct questioning |
Liu et al. (2020) |
675 previously hospitalized patients (21.5% had mild symptoms, 60.1% had moderate symptoms, 17.2% had severe symptoms, 1.2% were critically ill) Wuhan, China 47% male |
Median=55 Range=41-66 |
Not listed |
Mean of 36.75 days post discharge from hospital |
PHQ-9 GAD-7 PCL-5 5-item Perceived discrimination scale |
12.4% of patients were provisionally diagnosed with clinically significant PTSD symptoms 10.4% were categorized as having moderate to severe anxiety symptoms, with 32.3% reporting mild symptoms 19% were categorized as having moderate to severe depression symptoms, with 46.7% reporting mild symptoms Perceived discrimination, disease severity, living with children, and death of family member were predictors of mental health symptoms; mechanical ventilation was not associated with mental health outcomes |
Cross-sectional study which limits causal inference Mental health outcomes were cut off based on sum-score of diagnostic criteria, presenting potential threat to validity Medical comorbidities were not examined directly Lack of baseline psychological data |
Liu et al. (2021) |
324 patients: 6% asymtomatic, 73% had mild or moderate symptom 19% had severe/critical symptoms Shenzhen, China 47.8% male |
Asymptomatic: M=23.44 Mild/moderate: M=38.61 Severe/critical: M=57 Total: Range=0.3–86 |
Not listed |
Not listed |
Not listed |
Rates of anxiety was as follows: 11.94% among patients with mild/moderate symptoms, 10% among patients with severe/critical symptoms Rates of headache or insomnia were: 8.96% among patients with mild/moderate symptoms and 22.5% among patients with severe/critical symptoms |
Anxiety measure was not reported, outcome was subsequently described as 'anxiety/depression' Timing of anxiety assessment remains unclear |
Mandal et al. (2020) |
384 previously hospitalized patients (14.5% required ICU admission) UK 62% male |
M=59.9 SD=16.1 |
43% ethnic minority |
Median of 54 days post discharge from hospital |
PHQ-2 |
14.6% of patients endorsed depression a median of 54 days post discharge |
Abbreviated measure of depressive symptoms |
Mannan et al. (2021) |
1021 patients (10.9% were asymptomatic and 89.1% were symptomatic) 384 previously hospitalized patients (14.5% required ICU admission) Bangladesh 75% male |
0–9: N=18 10–19: N=50 20–29: N=248 30–39: N=309 40–49: N=171 50–59: N=126 >60: N=96 |
Not listed |
Received negative PCR result at least 4 weeks prior to the study |
Phone interview |
Most prevalent postrecovery complications included sleep disturbance (32%), weakened attention span (24.4%), anxiety and depression (23.1%), memory loss (19.5%), and complications with mobility (17.7%) Patients with medical comorbidity were found to be more likely to experience mobility problem (26%), weakness and problems performing usual activities (14%), anxiety and depression (28.5%), sleep disturbances (41.3%), concentration difficulties (28.5%), and memory loss (24.6%) than those without any comorbid conditions |
Measures used to assess cognitive and psychological functioning were not reported |
Mazza et al. (2020) |
402 patients who were presented to ED (74.6% were admitted for inpatient hospitalization and 25.4% were discharged home) Milan, Italy 65.7% male |
M=57.8 Range=18-87 |
Not listed |
Mean of 31.29 (SD=15.7) days post discharge from hospital, or mean of 28.56 (SD=11.73) days after ED admission |
IES-R PCL-5 BDI-13 STAI-Y WHIIRS Obsessive-Compulsive Inventory Zung Depression Scale Medical Outcomes Study Sleep Scale |
Rates of clinically significant psychopathology based on self-report: 28% for PTSD, 31% for depression, 42% for anxiety, 20% for obsessive-compulsive symptoms, and 40% for insomnia 55.7% endorsed clinical levels on at least 1 psychopathological dimension, with 36.8% endorsing clinical levels across 2 dimensions, 20.6% across 3 dimensions, and 10% across 4 dimensions Female patients with a previous psychiatric history, and patients who were discharged home reported greater difficulties on most measures |
Cross-sectional study |
Park et al. (2020) |
10 patients South Korea 80% male |
M=62.6 SD=14.9 |
Not listed |
1 month post discharge from hospital (median=25 days, range=13–50 days) |
PHQ-9 GAD-7 IES-R |
50% endorsed depressive symptoms during treatment 100% of patients denied significant anxiety after discharge At 1 month postdischarge, 10% endorsed symptoms of depression and PTSD Patients with high perceived stigma reported higher levels of PTSD symptoms Patients with a history of prior psychiatric treatment reported higher levels of PTSD symptoms, whereas levels of depression and anxiety did not differ as a function of treatment history |
Small sample size |
Raman et al. (2021) |
58 hospitalized patients (95% required mechanical ventilation, 36% required ICU admission) 30 uninfected matched controls UK 58.6% male |
M=55.4 SD=13.2 |
77.6% White, 22.4% Nonwhite |
Median of 2.3 months from disease-onset, median of 1.6 months post discharge from hospital |
PHQ-9 GAD-7 SF-36 MoCA MRC Fatigue Severity Scale |
Executive/visuospatial impairments were greater among patients compared to controls. Severity of illness did not predict levels of depression or anxiety At 2–3 months from disease-onset, patients reported significantly reduced quality of life and endorsed greater levels of depression, anxiety, and fatigue than controls did |
Small sample size Cross-sectional assessment Lack of correction for multiple comparisons Given that controls were not hospitalized, group differences may not be specific to COVID-19 infection |
Soldati et al. (2021) |
Soldati et al. (2021) 23 patients who were previously treated in the ICU Brazil 78.3% male |
M=53.6 SD=11.7 |
Not listed |
Ranged 43–136 days post discharge from hospital |
TICS EuroQol |
60.9% of patients fell within normal limits on cognitive assessments 13% met criteria for MCI MCI diagnosis was negatively associated with EuroQol scores No one exhibited severe levels of cognitive impairment on TICS Quality of education was inversely associated with cognitive functioning |
Lack of control group |
Speth et al. (2020) |
114 patients Switzerland 45.6% male |
M=44.6 SD=16.1 |
Not listed |
M=12.3 days (SD=7.2, range=0–31) following onset of COVID-19 symptoms |
PHQ-2 GAD-2 |
Depressed mood and anxiety were positively associated with chemosensory dysfunction but not positively associated with symptoms of fever, cough and shortness of breath Older age and preexisting depressive and anxiety symptoms were positively associated with levels of depression and anxiety across disease course |
Cross-sectional assessment Utilization of retrospective report Lack of objective measures of olfactory dysfunction |
Sykes et al. (2021) |
134 hospitalized patients (87% required supplemental oxygen or respirator support, 20% required ICU admission) UK 65.7% male |
M=59.6 SD=14 |
91% White, 1.5% Black, 6% Asian, 1.5% Mixed/other |
Median of 113 days (range: 46–167) post discharge from hospital |
MRC EQ-5D-5L |
86% reported at least one residual symptom, with the most frequently reported complaint being fatigue Illness severity was not associated with self-reported symptom burden Female sex was positively correlated with level of residual symptoms, particularly anxiety and fatigue Persistent COVID-related complications may not be directly attributable to SARS-CoV2 infection but, rather, the neuropsychiatric sequelae of the virus |
Severity of persistent symptoms was not Assessed |
Tomasoni et al. (2021) |
105 hospitalized patients (72% received minimal oxygen therapy whereas 22% were treated with CPAP, NIV or OTI) Milan, Italy 73.3% male |
Median=55 |
Not listed |
1–3 months (Median=46 days) after virological clearance |
HADS MMSE |
Among 25 patients who completed MMSE, 40% indicated cognitive impairment, which ranged from mild to severe Many patients continued to endorse anxiety (29%) and depression (11%) 1–3 months after virological clearance Clinical levels of HADS-A/D scores were positively associated with physical complaints |
Small sample size Only included patients with confirmed virological recovery, patients with persistent positive PCR after clinical recovery were excluded Lack of baseline psychological data |
Townsend et al. (2020) |
128 patients (55.4% were hospitalized, 44.6% were outpatients) Dublin, Ireland 46.1% male |
M=49.5 SD=15 |
Not listed |
Outpatients: at least 6 weeks after abatement of acute COVID-19 symptoms Hospitalized patients: date of discharge |
Chalder Fatigue Scale |
Mean psychological fatigue was 4.72 (SD=1.99) Treatment factors (hospitalization status, need for respiratory treatments) were not associated with fatigue levels Fatigue was positively associated with pre-existing depression and use of antidepressant medications |
Cross-sectional assessment |
Van den borst et al. (2020) |
124 patients (21.7% with mild disease, 41.1% with moderate, 20.9% with severe, 16.1% with critical disease); 78.2% required inpatient hospitalization Nijmegen, Netherlands 60% male |
M=59 SD=14 |
Not listed |
Outpatients: M=13.0 weeks (SD=2.2) symptom onset Hospitalized patients: M=9.1 weeks (SD=1.6) after discharge home |
HADS TICS PCL-5 IES-R SF-36 Cognitive Failures Questionnaire Nijmegen Clinical Screening Instrument |
Approximately 33% exhibited cognitive difficulties or atypical mental status Disease severity grade was not associated with mental or cognitive status in this study Many patients reported chronic, and severe, problems across health domains Referred mild disease patients displayed a female predominance and reported more frequently severe problems than moderate-to-critical disease, in the domains of physical functioning, quality of life, and energy |
Skewed distribution of prior health difficulties across disease severity groups; participants with mild disease had longstanding health impairments Diagnostic status not confirmed by PCR test for all participants |
Wang, et al. (2020) |
215 hospitalized patients Cleveland, US |
Not listed |
Not listed |
Not listed |
PTSD-5 GAD-7 CES-D10 |
57% screened positive for PTSD, anxiety, or depression. Specific rates were as follows: 34% for PTSD, 24% for anxiety, and 42% for depression Among patients without a prior psychiatric history, 42% screened positive for one psychiatric disorder Among patients with a prior psychiatric history, 78% screened positive for one disorder |
Utilization of self-report to characterize psychiatric history Not all patients were initially hospitalized due to COVID-19 |
Weerhandi et al. (2021) |
152 hospitalized patients (45.3% required ICU admission, 36.7% required mechanical ventilation) New York, US 62.7% male |
Median=62 Range=50–67 |
44.1% White, 21.7% Hispanic, 9/9% Asian, 11.2% Black, 8.7% Mixed/other, 4.4% unknown |
Median of 37 days (range: 30–43) post discharge from hospital |
the PROMIS Global Health-10 |
Poorer physical health and mental health were reported after hospital discharge compared to baseline functioning |
Strict exclusion criteria |
Woo et al. (2020) |
18 patients with mild to moderate disease (61% required inpatient hospitalization) 10 age-matched healthy controls Hamburg, Germany 42.1% male |
M=42.2 SD=14.3 |
Not listed |
Median of 85 days (Range=20–105 days) after recovery |
TICS-M PHQ-9 Fatigue Assessment Scale |
Patients exhibited greater difficulties on TICS-M as compared to healthy controls in the areas of short-term memory, attention, concentration/language 50% reported attention deficits, 44.4% reported short-term memory deficits, 27.8% reported word-finding difficulties, 16.7% reported fatigue, 11.1% reported mood swings, and 5.6% reported fatigue, phonophobia, or incoherent thoughts Cognitive functioning was not associated with somatic symptoms Disease severity and treatment factors were not associated with cognitive impairments |
Small sample size Screening measure of cognitive functioning |
Zarghami et al.(2020) |
50 outpatients with mild symptomatology Fasa City, Iran |
M=43.62 SD=15.81 |
Not listed |
During home quarantine |
PHQ-9 GAD-7 PSS-14 Semi-structured psychiatric interview |
17.3% patients had prior history of psychiatric disorders Based on self-report measure, 34.6% endorsed depressive symptoms, 32.7% endorsed anxiety, and mean score for PSS-14 is 11.8 (scores range from 0–56) Based on clinical interview, 18.8% met criteria for a psychiatric disorder; specific rates were as follows: 5.8% for GAD, 21.2% for insomnia, 3.8% for MDD, and 9.6% for an adjustment disorder |
Small sample size |
Zhou et al. (2020) |
29 recovered patients 29 healthy controls Zhejiang, China 62% male |
M=47 SD=10.54 Range=30-64 |
Chinese Han |
2–3 weeks after infection |
TMT Digit Span Sign Coding Test CPT GAD-7 PHQ-9 |
Cognitive impairments among patients with SARS-CoV-2 were mild and most prominent in the domain of sustained attention No significant difference between patient and healthy controls in TMT, SCT, or DST |
Small sample size Participants excluded if they received fewer than nine years of education |
Zhu et al. (2020) |
432 previously hospitalized patients China 51% male |
Median=49, range=35-60 |
Chinese Han and Tibetan |
Not listed |
Lawton IADL scale Barthel Index Zung's self-reported anxiety scale |
36.8% of patients reported at least one IADL limitation, with 16.4% reporting moderate dependence and 5.6% reporting severe dependence 28.7% of patients met criteria for a probable anxiety disorder diagnosis Disease severity was associated with greater prevalence of disability and anxiety and was an independent risk factor for all outcomes |
Lack of baseline data Lack of control group Reliance on self-report measures Cross-sectional assessment |