Editor's note: Find the latest COVID-19 news and guidance in Medscape's Coronavirus Resource Center.
Among COVID-19 patients who undergo mechanical ventilation, lying in the prone position has been associated with lasting nerve damage.
A new case series describes peripheral nerve injuries associated with this type of positioning and suggests ways to minimize the potential damage.
"Physicians should remain aware of increased susceptibility to peripheral nerve damage in patients with severe COVID-19 after prone positioning, since it is surprisingly common among these patients, and should refine standard protocols accordingly to reduce that risk," senior author Colin Franz, MD, PhD, director of the Electrodiagnostic Laboratory, Shirley Ryan AbilityLab, Chicago, Illinois, told Medscape Medical News.
The article was published online September 4 in the British Journal of Anaesthesiology.
Unique Type of Nerve Injury
Many patients who are admitted to the intensive care unit (ICU) with COVID-19 undergo invasive mechanical ventilation because of acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Clinical guidelines recommend that such patients lie in the prone position 12 to 16 hours per day.
"Prone positioning for up to 16 hours is a therapy we use for patients with more severe forms of ARDS, and high-level evidence points to mortality benefit in patients with moderate to severe ARDS if [mechanical] ventilation occurs," said study coauthor James McCauley Walter, MD, assistant professor, pulmonary division, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
With a "significant number of COVID-19 patients flooding the ICU, we quickly started to prone a lot of them, but if you are in a specific position for multiple hours a day, coupled with the neurotoxic effects of the SARS-CoV-2 virus itself, you may be exposed to a unique type of nerve injury," he said.
Water said that the "incidence of asymmetric neuropathies seem [is] out of proportion to what has been reported in non-COVID-19 settings, which is what caught our attention."
Many of these patients are discharged to rehabilitation hospitals, and "what we noticed, which was unique about COVID-19 patients coming to our rehab hospital, was that compared to other patients who had been critically ill with a long hospital stay, there was a significantly higher percentage of COVID-19 patients who had peripheral nerve damage," Franz said.
The authors describe 12 of these patients who were admitted between April 24 and June 30, 2020 (mean age, 60.3 years; range, 23 – 80 years). The sample included White, Black, and Hispanic individuals.
Eleven of the 12 post-COVID-19 patients with peripheral nerve damage had experienced prone positioning during acute management.
The average number of days patients received mechanical ventilation was 33.6 (range, 12 – 62 days). The average number of proning sessions was 4.5 (range, 1 – 16) with an average of 81.2 hours (range, 16 – 252 hours) spent prone.
Table. The Most Common Sites of Injury
|Ulnar nerve||Six cases (28.6%)|
|Radial nerve||Three cases (14.3%)|
|Sciatic nerve||Three cases (14.3%)|
|Brachial plexus||Two cases (9.5%)|
|Median nerve||Two cases (9.5%)|
A Major Contributor
Franz suggested that prone positioning is likely not the only cause of peripheral nerve damage but "may play a big role in these patients who are vulnerable because of viral infection and the critical illness that causes damage and nerve injuries."
"The first component of lifesaving care for the critically ill in the ICU is intravenous fluids, mechanical ventilation, steroids, and antibiotics for infection," said Walter.
"We are trying to come up with ways to place patients in prone position in safer ways, to pay attention to pressure points and areas of injury that we have seen and try to offload them, to see if we can decrease the rate of these injuries," he added
The researchers' article includes a heat map diagram as a "template for where to focus the most efforts, in terms of decreasing pressure," Walter said.
"The nerves are accepting too much force for gravely ill COVID-19 patients to handle, so we suggest using the template to determine where extra padding might be needed, or a protocol that might include changes in positioning," he added.
Franz described the interventions used for COVID-19 patients with prone positioning–related peripheral nerve damage.
"The first step is trying to address the problems one by one, either trying to solve them through exercise or teaching new skills, new ways to compensate, beginning with basic activities, such as getting out of bed and self-care," he said.
Long-term recovery of nerve injuries depends on how severe the injuries are. Some nerves can slowly regenerate — possibly at the rate of 1 inch per month — which can be a long process, taking between a year and 18 months.
Franz said that therapies for this condition are "extrapolated from clinical trial work" on promoting nerve regeneration after surgery using electrical stimulation to enable nerves to regrow at a faster rate.
"Regeneration is not only slow, but it may not happen completely, leaving the patient with permanent nerve damage — in fact, based on our experience and what has been reported, the percentage of patients with full recovery is only 10%," he said.
The most common symptomatic complaint other than lack of movement or feeling is neuropathic pain, "which may require medication to take the edge off the pain," Franz added.
Commenting on the study for Medscape Medical News, Tae Chung, MD, assistant professor of physical medicine, rehabilitation, and neurology, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland, said the study "provides one of the first and the largest description of peripheral nerve injury associated with prone positioning for management of ARDS from COVID-19."
Chung, who was not involved in the research, noted that "various neurological complications from COVID-19 have been reported, and some of them may result in irreversible neurological damage or delay the recovery from COVID-19 infection," so "accurate and timely diagnosis of such neurological complications is critical for rehabilitation of the COVID-19 survivors."
The study received no funding. Franz, Walter, study coauthors, and Chung report no relevant financial relationships.
Br J Anaesth. Published online September 4, 2020. Full text
Medscape Medical News © 2020
Cite this: Nerve Damage Linked to Prone Positioning in COVID-19 - Medscape - Sep 28, 2020.