Editor's note: Find the latest COVID-19 news and guidance in Medscape's Coronavirus Resource Center.
The medical community is about to find out how prepared it is for the double whammy of influenza and COVID-19 that has been predicted for the fall of 2020. The complexities of diagnosis, management of vulnerable patients, and overflowing medical centers that have made the COVID-19 crisis so brutal may all be exacerbated by the arrival of seasonal influenza.
Lewis Jay Kaplan, MD, FCCP, a critical care surgeon at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, has seen his share of critically ill COVID-19 patients in the surgical ICU that he oversees. He's approaching the upcoming flu season, poised to collide with the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, ready to listen to each patient's story to distinguish one from the other and determine treatment.
"The patients that have underlying comorbidities all have a story, and it's up to you to figure out which chapter you're in and how far along you happen to be," he said. "It's a very interesting approach to care, medical storytelling."
With flu season closing in, pulmonologists are ruminating about how they'll distinguish symptoms of COVID-19 and traditional influenza and how they'll manage the most vulnerable patients, namely those with underlying respiratory disease and children. Influenza kills 12,000-61,000 people a year, according to the Centers for Disease Control, and results in 140,000-810,00 hospitalizations. Having a flu season in the midst of a pandemic of a disease with multiple overlapping symptoms threatens to overwhelm practitioners, hospitals, and the health system.
Dr. Kaplan said each patient's story can point to the correct clinical approach. "Instead of just sharing data when you are on rounds, you're really telling someone's story." It arises from a series of questions about how the disease has impacted them, specifics of their presentation, how their signs and symptoms differ from the usual, and how they responded to treatment. "It also helps you to then take what you're doing, which can seem very, very complicated to individuals who are not medically sophisticated, and then help them to understand why you're doing what you're doing at this point."
That can help get through to a patient with respiratory disease who insists he or she has or doesn't have COVID-19 rather than the flu. "They form a different group that brings with them different fears and concerns, and you have to help them navigate that, too: all of this data and your decision-making around testing and admissions, and what you can omit doing and what you must do help them to navigate their own story," Dr. Kaplan said.
Benjamin D. Singer, MD, a pulmonologist at Northwestern University, Chicago, authored an editorial in Science Advances that addressed four factors that will determine the scope of flu spread in the upcoming season: rate of transmission; vaccination rates; coinfection rates; and health disparities in minority populations, which are prone to higher rates of flu as well as COVID-19.
Flu Vaccine "Extra Important"
The convergence of COVID-19 and influenza has the potential to overwhelm the health system, said Daniel A. Solomon, MD, of Brigham and Women's in Boston. He coauthored a JAMA Insights clinical update on flu season during the COVID-19 pandemic that lists distinguishing and overlapping signs and symptoms of the two diseases.
The flu vaccine, he said, is "extra important this year," especially in patients with existing respiratory disease, but COVID-19 has thrown up barriers to vaccination. Telemedicine has supplanted office visits. "People may miss that easy-touch opportunity to get the flu vaccine, so we have to be creative about making the flu vaccine highly accessible, maybe in nontraditional ways," Dr. Solomon said. Some ideas he offered are pop-up vaccine fairs at schools and churches.
But just as COVID-19 may hinder flu vaccines, it may also be helping to mitigate flu transmission. "The interesting thing about transmission of the flu is that it's transmitted the same way COVID is, so if we actually know how to decrease transmission of COVID, which we do – we've done it – we can actually decrease transmission of influenza as well," Dr. Solomon said. Studies out of Hong Kong and Japan have reported a reduction in influenza cases during COVID-19 outbreaks in those places (Lancet Public Health. 2020;5:e279-88; JAMA. 2020;323:1969-71).
Risks of Coinfection
About one in four COVID-19 patients have been diagnosed with an additional respiratory infection, including influenza (JAMA. 2020:323:2085-6). Pulmonologists must keep that in mind when managing COVID-19 suspects, said Dr. Singer.
"While it is true that most of the time COVID-19 travels alone, we have numerous examples in the literature and in our own experience that COVID-19 is accompanied by either another virus or another bacterial infection, including influenza," Dr. Singer said. "The distinction is important. One is just for diagnostic reasons and public reporting reasons, but also because flu and COVID-19 have different requirements for how you care for patients in terms of the health system."
Clinical suspicion for coinfection should remain high if the community spread of both COVID-19 and influenza is high, said Megan Conroy, MD, chief pulmonary and critical care fellow at Ohio State University, Columbus. "As the coronavirus first took hold in the United States in March 2020, we were at the tail end of influenza season, so it's hard to predict what the upcoming influenza season will really look like with regards to coinfection."
Distinguishing COVID-19 From Flu
Multiple signs and symptoms between COVID-19 and the flu overlap. They include fever, chills, headache, myalgia, cough, and fatigue. Nasal congestion and sore throat are characteristic of the flu; shortness of breath and loss of the sense of smell have been widely reported in COVID-19. "While many upper respiratory infections can result in loss of smell, this may be more prevalent in COVID-19," Dr. Conroy said. Other symptoms unique to COVID-19 are GI symptoms such as diarrhea and skin rashes such as acral ischemia.
Testing, however, is the cornerstone of the differential diagnosis. "You can't confidently distinguish between them on symptoms alone," Dr. Conroy added.
"I think the challenge we'll face as clinicians, is caring for people with nonspecific symptoms of a respiratory viral illness, especially in the early phase of the illness," said Dr. Solomon.
But even after that, symptoms can be difficult to distinguish.
"Later in the illness, COVID is more associated with a hypercoagulable state," he said. "It is more associated with viral pneumonia on chest imaging, like the diffuse ground-glass infiltrates that we've all gotten used to seeing – but flu can do both of those things as well. So, without a test, it's impossible to distinguish between the two infections in the clinic."
But testing can have its shortcomings when flu season clashes with the COVID-19 pandemic. "Getting the test is not the same as getting the test results," Dr. Solomon added. "Though a lot of people can get a test, if it takes 7 or 8 days to get the test result back, the result is useless."
Widespread, rapid testing also depends on having adequate supplies of viral media transport and swabs. "I think that this is what we should be focusing on now: scaling up access to rapid turnaround testing," he said. Distinguishing between the two is also important to preserve hospital resources. COVID-19 has more rigorous standards than flu for personal protective equipment and isolation of patients within the hospital.
Having chronic lung disease isn't necessarily a risk factor for contracting COVID-19 or the flu, or both, Dr. Solomon said. "It's a risk factor for having severe disease." Again, he noted that flu vaccines are still necessary in these patients, as well as patients of advanced age and underlying medical conditions such as heart disease, diabetes, and obesity.
In managing children, it's important to keep in mind that they communicate differently about their illnesses than adults, said Dr. Kaplan. "They may not have the words to tell you the same kind of thing that the adult tells you." That's where family members can help to flesh out the history. "They may present with an initially much milder form, if you will, where they're not as critical up front, but then that small proportion of them comes back with the multi-inflammatory syndrome and then they are profoundly ill."
Younger people make up a larger share of COVID-19 patients now, compared with the initial wave that hit the Northeast in the spring, Dr. Kaplan said. "We don't know if that's because the virus is a little different or the people that are getting sick are a little bit different."
The COVID-19 strain now emerging may be less virulent than the strain that hit in early spring, he said. "That doesn't mean that there aren't still profoundly critical ill people with COVID of many different age ranges, that is true, but there are a lot of people that we now see will test positive, but aren't really as profoundly ill as when it first landed here in the United States."
That may be somewhat welcome as flu season arrives.
The physicians interviewed have no relevant disclosures.
This article originally appeared on MDedge.com, part of the Medscape Professional Network.
Medscape Medical News © 2020
Cite this: When Viruses Collide: Flu Season During Pandemic - Medscape - Aug 27, 2020.