Most Residents Say Work/Life Balance Is First Priority in Job Hunt

Marcia Frellick

August 09, 2019

Most residents (75%) in a new Medscape survey listed work/life balance as the top factor they will consider in choosing their first job as a physician.

They prioritized having a good work schedule and reasonable call over starting salary (64%) and having a supportive organizational and practice environment (53%).

Responses from more than 2200 residents in 30 specialties were included in the Medscape Residents Lifestyle & Happiness Report 2019. They answered questions about their joys and frustrations in training and their view of their future as doctors.

 

Again this year, work/life balance was residents' biggest challenge. Thirty-one percent of residents in years 1-4 said it was their biggest difficulty (33% for those in years 5-8). The next biggest challenge was dealing with time pressures (20% in years 1-4; 22% in years 5-8), followed by debt (14% in years 1-4 and 13% in years 5-8 said it was their biggest challenge).

For some, the imbalance was a surprise. Nearly a third (32%) said work/life balance was somewhat or much worse than they expected, while 24% said it was somewhat or much better. Forty-four percent said it was neither better nor worse.

More than two-thirds (69%) of residents said they have had a personal relationship fail because they don't have time to lead the kind of social life they would like.

Personal wellness time was elusive for some residents. Forty-six percent said they only sometimes have time for wellness and 34% said they rarely or never have time for that.

Bullying, Harassment Continues

Responses indicated that bullying and harassment persist to some degree in residency — particularly against women. Asked whether bullying was a problem in medical school, 4% said often; 20% said occasionally; 37% said rarely; and 39% said never.

Women (68%) reported higher rates of bullying than men (58%).

Additionally, 41% of women and 15% of men reported they personally had experienced either sexual abuse, or sexual harassment or misconduct during residency. As to the frequency, 1% of men and 2% of women said it was often; 3% of men and 12% of women said it was occasional; and 11% of women and 27% of men said it happened rarely.

Asked whether they had reported the sexual harassment or abuse, only 18% of residents said yes.

11% Have Had Suicidal Thoughts

The numbers of residents who have had suicidal thoughts rose slightly this year, to 11% from 10%, though no respondents said they had attempted suicide in either year.

The numbers reporting depression have been fairly consistent for years. In this survey, 8% said they were depressed always or most of the time; 29% said they sometimes were; 58% said they were rarely or never depressed; and 5% preferred not to answer.

Two-thirds of residents said in the survey that they somewhat or strongly agree there is a stigma around seeking help.

Burnout

When asked what would make the most difference in helping avoid burnout, the number-one answer by far from residents was a manageable work schedule and call hours (64%). The next most common answer was sufficient compensation to avoid financial stress (43%), followed by reasonable patient loads (40%).

More workplaces are becoming proactive in helping residents reduce stress. In this year’s survey, 57% said their workplace has a program in place for stress reduction.

For those who don't take advantage of such programs, reasons given included: "Good way to end up on [administration's] radar. No thanks!"; "Don't need now, but glad resources are there should I need them later"; "I have other ways to relieve stress"; "If I go it places burden on my colleagues [to cover for me]"; and "no time."

Less Worry That More Work Hours Will Up Errors

Controversy continues over the increase in work hours in 2017 that allowed for first-year residents to work 28 consecutive hours. But this year the number who said longer shift hours will lead to more errors was 35%, down from just more than half who answered that way in the 2017 survey.

The vast majority of residents said they were optimistic about their careers: 86% said they were looking forward to being doctors, 10% were unsure, and 4% said they were not looking forward to starting their careers.

The most rewarding aspect of residency for three-quarters of the respondents was the knowledge and experience they were gaining, followed closely by gratitude from and relationships with patients and "being very good at what I do."

For more news, follow Medscape on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube.

Comments

3090D553-9492-4563-8681-AD288FA52ACE
Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.
Post as:

processing....