Kale Is a Surprise on 2019's 'Dirty Dozen' List

Kathleen Doheny

March 20, 2019

While it may still be considered a super food, kale took third place on this year's "Dirty Dozen" list of fruits and vegetables with the most pesticide residue. Once again, strawberries and spinach took first and second, as they did on last year's list.

The Environmental Working Group (EWG), a nonprofit organization focused on human health and the environment, has produced the report annually since 2004.

This year, more than 92% of kale samples tested had two or more pesticide residues detected, and a single sample could have up to 18 different residues, EWG found. The most frequently detected pesticide, found on about 60% of the kale samples, was Dacthal, also called DCPA. It has been classified by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as a possible human carcinogen, based on animal studies.

The EWG researchers analyzed test data from the U.S. Department of Agriculture for the report, and kale had not been tested in more than 10 years, says Nneka Leiba, MPH, director of healthy living science at EWG and a co-author of the report. "The percent of [kale] samples with residue increased from 76% to 98%," she says, citing the difference between the testing in 2007 and in 2017, the data used for this year's report. "The average number of residues on a single sample increased from two to more than five."

Leiba stresses that the report should not discourage people from eating fruits and vegetables, although she does suggest people choose organic produce when possible as even washing produce does not remove all pesticides.

Other experts who viewed the report say the amount of pesticides found is not high enough to be a health hazard.

2019's Dirty Dozen

After adding kale, this year's list repeats all the entries on last year's list except for sweet bell peppers, in 12th place last year. This year's Dirty Dozen:

  1. Strawberries

  2. Spinach

  3. Kale

  4. Nectarines

  5. Apples

  6. Grapes

  7. Peaches

  8. Cherries

  9. Pears

  10. Tomatoes

  11. Celery

  12. Potatoes

Dirty Dozen Plus

The researchers also call out hot peppers, which they say don't meet their traditional ranking criteria but "were found to be contaminated with insecticides toxic to the human nervous system." They found insecticides that are banned on some crops but still allowed for use on hot peppers: acephate, chlorpyrifos, and oxamyl. The EWG recommends buying organic hot peppers or cooking them, as the heat decreases pesticide levels.

Clean 15 List for 2019

The researchers also produce a Clean 15 list ― produce least likely to have pesticide residue. Much of this year's list also repeats last year's. For 2019, mushrooms made the list, while mangoes dropped off. Overall, more than 70% of the fruit and vegetable samples on the Clean 15 list had no pesticide residues, the researchers found. If they did have residues, only 6% had two or more pesticide types.

  1. Avocados (less than 1% of samples showed detectable levels of pesticides)

  2. Sweet corn (less than 1% of samples showed detectable levels)

  3. Pineapples

  4. Frozen sweet peas

  5. Onions

  6. Papayas

  7. Eggplants

  8. Asparagus

  9. Kiwis

  10. Cabbages

  11. Cauliflower

  12. Cantaloupes

  13. Broccoli

  14. Mushrooms

  15. Honeydew melons

Study Methods, Health Concerns

For the report, researchers ranked pesticide contamination of 47 fruits and vegetables based on an analysis of more than 40,000 samples taken by the USDA and FDA. The researchers looked at the percent tested with detectable pesticides, the percent with two or more, average number on a single sample, average amount of pesticides found, maximum number found on a single sample, and total found on the crop.

EWG researchers point to the value of a diet low in pesticide residues, citing research such as a recent report finding that people with the highest frequency of organic food consumption had a 25% lower risk of cancers of various types than those who had the lowest intake. Another study found a link between eating foods high in pesticide residues and fertility issues.

A Toxicologist Weighs In

Carl Winter, PhD, a food toxicologist at the University of California Davis, is familiar with the EWG reports. He calls the rankings "arbitrary and of dubious value for consumers."

When considering the risk of pesticides in food, he says, the actual amount of pesticide detected, the amount of that food eaten by a person, and the toxicity of the pesticide must all be evaluated, and he says the EWG research does not do this.

A Dietitian's Viewpoint

"As a registered dietitian, the concept of 'dirty' and 'clean' foods is concerning, unless food is truly dirty," says Connie Diekman, a registered dietitian and director of university nutrition at Washington University in St. Louis.

She reviewed the report. "The USDA, FDA, and EPA all work to develop guidelines for safe food, setting limits of additives, preservatives, and pesticides at levels that are significantly below levels that might be a concern," she says. She cautions consumers not to fear certain produce.

The amount of pesticides used is small, she says, "and the quantity of food we would need to eat for any potential health risk exceeds what people do [eat]."

"If you are more comfortable and can afford to, buy organic, but know it can have organic pesticide residue," Diekman says.

Growers' Views

Teresa Thorne is executive director of the Alliance for Food and Farming, an industry group representing farmers who grow both organic and conventional produce. She fears that the report will create "unfounded and unnecessary fears." She notes that few Americans eat enough fruits and vegetable daily as is.

The Alliance maintains a pesticide calculator on its companion site, www.safefruitsandveggies.com. According to its calculations, a child could eat 7,446 servings of kale in one day without ill effect, even if it had the highest pesticide residue recorded by the USDA.

EWG Responds

While the levels on individual produce may seem low, "the overall burden is high," Leiba says, adding that people are also eating other foods with chemicals and pesticides. "We are talking about a synergistic effect."

Editor's note: Connie Diekman is on the Bayer LEAD Network, Leaders Engaged in Advancing Dialogue.

Sources

Environmental Working Group's 2019 Shopper's Guide to Pesticides in Produce, March 20, 2019.

Nneka Leiba, MPH, director of healthy living science, Environmental Working Group.

Connie Diekman, MEd, RD, director of university nutrition, Washington University in St. Louis; former president, Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics.

Carl Winter, PhD, food toxicologist, University of California, Davis.

Teresa Thorne, executive director, Alliance for Food and Farming.

JAMA Internal Medicine, December 2018.

Comments

3090D553-9492-4563-8681-AD288FA52ACE
Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.
Post as:

processing....