New Diagnostic Test for Parkinson's?

Pauline Anderson

February 08, 2016

Transcutaneous needle biopsy of the submandibular gland may identify Lewy-type synucleinopathy (LTS) in patients with early Parkinson's disease (PD).

A new study shows that LTS was present in the submandibular glands — which play a role in making saliva — of almost three quarters of the assessable glandular tissue specimens from patients with PD.

Currently, the diagnosis of PD relies on clinical examinations, so developing a test to determine whether a patient has this disorder would be helpful in both the research setting and clinically, said lead author Charles H. Adler, MD, PhD, professor, neurology, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, Scottsdale, Arizona.

In PD, α-synuclein proteins are found not only in the brain but throughout the body, including in the colon, stomach, olfactory bulb, and esophagus. The best place to biopsy would be the brain, but that, of course, is impossible. Compared with other potential sites from which to obtain tissue, the submandibular gland is the easiest to reach and potentially the safest, posing the fewest risks for side effects, said Dr Adler.

The study was published in the February issue of Movement Disorders.

The analysis included 25 patients diagnosed with PD within the previous 5 years (mean age, 69.8 years; 64% male) plus 10 controls (mean age, 64.7 years; 30% male), who had no evidence of a neurodegenerative disorder.

The patients with PD were required to have a dopamine transporter (DaT) scan. As Dr Adler explained, one marker of PD is a positive DaT scan, which indicates loss of dopamine nerves, although the test isn't specific to PD.

Smell Tests

All study participants had olfactory testing with the University of Pennsylvania Smell Identification Test (UPSIT-40), a kind of scratch-and-sniff test. Most patients with PD lose some sense of smell, likely partly because of degeneration of the olfactory bulb, said Dr Adler.

Again, this test isn't specific to PD, "but if you lose your sense of smell and have a positive DaT scan, the likelihood that you have PD goes up and up," he said.

For the biopsy, participants underwent local anesthesia, after which an ear, nose, and throat specialist inserted a needle through the skin, into the submandibular gland, to obtain three to six needle cores. All biopsies were performed unilaterally. There was no difference in the mean number of needle cores taken per participant.

Slides were examined by experts blinded to clinical diagnosis, DaT scan, and smell test results. The total number of slides reviewed did not differ between LTS-positive and -negative groups.

Tissues from 7 patients with PD and 1 control were insufficient for determining whether LTS was present, leaving 18 patients with PD and 9 controls. However, 1 of the 7 PD cases was later found to be LTS positive and so was included in the LTS-positive group analysis.

Overall, 14 (74%) of the 19 patients with PD had biopsy specimens positive for LTS. Five patients with PD were negative, probably because the affected tissue was missed, said Dr Adler.

Another possibility is that these patients don't actually have PD.

Of the 9 controls with adequate glandular tissue, 2 (22%) had LTS. "It could mean that these people have PD that we haven't seen signs of yet," said Dr Adler, although he personally examined them and saw no signs of PD.

It's also possible that these were false-positive results, he said.

The PD group had significantly more olfactory dysfunction than controls (mean UPSIT score of 18.4 vs 35.7; P < .001). But there was no significant difference in mean UPSIT scores between the LTS-positive and negative patients with PD (15.4 and 19.6; P = .27).

"This suggests that those [negative] patients probably have PD or they certainly have a neurodegenerative disorder that's affected their sense of smell," said Dr Adler.

These negative patients with PD also had abnormal DaT scans, indicating that their dopamine levels were low.

"So the 2 things we use as markers to try to figure out if someone has a neurodegenerative disorder were both abnormal," said Dr. Adler. "I still believe that most of the 5 [negative PD patients] probably do have PD; it's just a matter of needle probably missing the tissue."

Dr Adler said he doesn't think it's important that the percentage of men was lower in the control group, especially considering the small sample size.

Side effects of the biopsy mostly included swelling and bruising, which were minor and transient.

Patient Selection

Dr Adler sees this biopsy test being used by researcher who strive to enroll patients in treatment trials early in the course of the disease. Now, they have to rely on sometimes inaccurate clinical examinations for diagnostic information.

"If you were to enroll 100 people in a placebo group and 100 people in an active drug group, and let's say 25% in both groups didn't have PD, then you probably powered the study wrong," said Dr Adler. "And so drugs that were noneffective may actually have been effective if everybody had had PD."

Clinically, the biopsy test could help prevent patients who don't have PD from being subjected to sometimes invasive treatments, such as deep-brain stimulation, stem cell transplants, and injections of levodopa gel into the intestines.

"All the invasive therapies pretty much only work in people with PD, so if they have another neurodegenerative disease, they won't work," said Dr Adler. "This would be an opportunity, if the test turns out to be as accurate as we hope, to be absolutely sure that the person you're sending for an invasive treatment is someone you should send for an invasive treatment."

Dr Adler's site is involved in a Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson's Research–funded initiative, the Systemic Synuclein Sampling (S4) Study. Researchers will take biopsy samples of the skin, colon, and submandibular gland as well as samples of saliva, and spinal fluid, in the same patients with PD and controls, to see which offers the best biomarker.

Medscape Medical News asked Michael S. Okun, MD, professor and chair, neurology, University of Florida, Gainesville, and national medical director, National Parkinson Foundation, to comment on the study.

"The idea of developing a simple test to diagnose early Parkinson's disease is not only appealing, but it will be critically important to the field," said Dr Okun.

That two of the controls in the study had a positive biopsy "raises the important question about the diagnostic accuracy of the test," said Dr Okun. On the other hand, this finding "also raises the intriguing possibility that the authors may have uncovered prodromal Parkinson's disease."

Although the results are "intriguing," Dr Okun said they "don't suggest that in its current form a submandibular biopsy will become the gold standard for early Parkinson's disease diagnosis."

However, he added that improvements on the technique "may change this status in the near future."

The study was funded by the Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson's Research. The authors have disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

Mov Disord. Published online January 22, 2016. Abstract


Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.
Post as: