Study, location; duration, follow-up |
Trial design (sample size, n) |
TCM ingredients, dosage, administration |
APP (conventional antipsoriatic therapy) dosage, administration |
Outcome measures: results |
AEs |
Trials with oral CHM as primary intervention |
Liu et al. [78], Huangshi, China; 4 weeks, NS |
Oral CHM + topical APP (42) vs. topical APP (42) |
Commercial Binghuang Ointment, qd (night) for 4 weeks |
Tazarotene 0.05 % gel, 2× day, for 4 weeks |
Reduction in PASI: T>C (p<0.05) |
Slight itching and burning (T: 3, C: 5) |
Zhang [79], China; 4 weeks, no follow-up |
Oral CHM + acitretin (56) vs. acitretin alone (56) |
CHM decoction (Qing Ying Tang), tid, no individual modification |
Oral acitretin capsules: 10 mg tid |
TER based on lesions reduction 75 %: T>C for TER; ES for 75 % lesion reduction: RR 1.64 (CI 1.23–2.19) |
NS |
Zheng [80], China; 8 weeks, no follow-up |
Oral CHM + acitretin (60) vs. acitretin alone (60) |
CHM decoction (Xiao Yin Ke Bi Tang), bid, no individual modification |
Oral acitretin capsules: started at 20 mg/day, then increased to 30–40 mg/day, then decreased to 10–20 mg/day |
TER based on PASI 60; PASI score: T>C for TER and PASI score; ES for PASI 60: RR 2.00 (CI 1.21–3.32); ES for PASI score: MD -2.45 (CI -3.60 to -1.30) |
Mild in both groups: GI reactions in both groups; leukocyte decrease in C group only; no SAE |
Luo [81], China; 6 weeks, no follow-up |
Oral CHM + acitretin + co-interventions (74) vs. acitretin + co-interventionsb (100) |
CHM decoction (no formula name), bid, no individual modification |
Oral acitretin capsules: 0.5 mg/kg per day; IV complex glycyrrhizin, 30 ml qd; topical calcipotriol, bid |
TER based on PASI 60: T>C for TER; ES for PASI 60: RR 1.71 (CI 1.30–2.24) |
Mild in C group only, caused by pharmacotherapies; no SAE |
Wang et al. [82], Changchun, China; 6 weeks, NS |
Oral CHM + topical and systemic APP (22) vs. topical and systemic APP (20) |
Herbal bath as 3000 ml bath for 20–30 min 1×day for weeks 1–2, then 1 × 2 days for weeks 3–4, then 2× week for weeks 5–6 |
Salicylic acid cream 2× day, methotrexate, oral 5–15 mg/week |
Overall clinical efficacya: T>C (χ2 = 8.24, p<0.05) |
Hair loss (T: 1), slightly increased ALT (T: 1 = 50 U/L; C: 1 = 55 U/L), stomach discomfort (T: 1, C: 2) |
Wu [83], China; 12 weeks, no follow-up |
Oral CHM + acitretin + co-interventionsb (79) vs. acitretin + co-interventionsb (79) |
CHM decoction (Yin Xie Kang), qd, individual modification according to symptoms |
Oral acitretin capsules: 0.5 mg/kg/day; boric acid ointment, bid |
TER based on PASI 60; PASI score; liver and kidney function: T>C for TER and PASI score; ES for PASI 60: RR 1.32 (CI 1.11–1.57); ES for PASI score: MD −4.03 (CI −4.97 to −3.09) |
Mild in both groups, dry and scaly skin, due to pharmacotherapy, T<C; no SAE |
Yang et al. [84], Xiangfan, China; 4 weeks, 6 months |
Oral CHM + topical APP (82) vs. topical APP (47) |
Herbal bath decocted in water adequate for a body bath. Frequency of use not specified |
Halcinolone acetonide cream 2× day, thymosin IV solution 40 mg/day |
Overall clinical efficacya: T>C (χ2 = 4.649, p<0.05) Follow-up relapse: T: 1 (3.55 %), C: 2 (18.2 %) |
No obvious issues |
Yang et al. [85], Luzhou, China; 4 weeks, NS |
Oral CHM + topical and systemic APP (58) vs. topical and systemic APP (46) |
Herbal steam with additions of various herbs according to individual syndromes Applied using specific device, 20 min/day for 5 days, 2 days' break, for 4 weeks |
Hydrocortisone butyrate cream 2 × day, urea cream 29 days, acitretin capsules, oral 30–40 mg 1× day |
Overall clinical efficacya: T>C (χ2 = 9. 91, p<0.01) |
(T/C): dry mouth, dry lips and chapped lips (44/46), dry eyes (28/38), dry skin on body (22/34), epistaxis (4/6), body itching (13/19), desquamation (11/25), increased ALT (2/8), hyperlipidemia (1/1) |
Feng et al. [86], Beijing, China; 3 weeks, NS |
Oral CHM + topical APP (32) vs. topical APP (33) |
Herbal bath, various herbs totaling 20 g in 2000 ml water, 20 min, 19 days, for 3 weeks |
Kangminzhiyang cream (triamcinolone acetonide) 2× day, ammonium glycyrrhizinate IV solution 150 mg/day |
Reduction in lesion area: T>C (χ2 = 5.54, p = 0.019); clearance time: T<C (χ2 = 4.32, p = 0.001); lesion score: itching T<C (χ2 2.72, p = 0.008), scaling T<C (χ2 = 2.84, p = 0.006), erythema and induration (not significant) |
Slight dizziness and palpitation (T: 2) |
Mao and Mao [87], China; 8 weeks, 3 months |
Oral CHM + acitretin + co-interventionsb (31) vs. acitretin + co-interventionsb (31) |
CHM decoction (no name), bid, individual modification according to psoriasis vulgaris stage |
Oral acitretin capsules, 10 mg bid; oral 'Diyin' tablets, five tablets bid |
TER based on PASI 60; recurrence rate; liver and kidney function: T>C for TER; ES for PASI 60: RR 1.09 (CI 0.81–1.46) |
Mild skin dryness, pruritus, T/C: (1/3); no SAE |
Han et al. [88], Huangshi, China; 4 weeks, NS |
Oral CHM + topical APP (43) vs. topical APP (32) |
Commercial Binghuangfule ointment qd |
Clobetasol cream qd |
PASI T ≈ C (χ2 = 0.327, p<0.05); overall clinical efficacya: T ≈ C (χ2 = 0.040, p>0.05); follow-up relapse: T: 5 (26.32 %), C: 8 (47.06 %) |
Skin pigmentation (C: 1), hypopigmentation and skin atrophy (C: 2), Malassezia folliculitis (C: 3), skin pigmentation (T: 2) |
Tang [89]; Hangzhou, China; 10 times (over 10–20 days), NS |
Oral CHM + topical APP (36) vs. topical APP (36) |
Herbal bath of various herbs, each 60 g of raw herbs. In warm bath, 1:40,000, 30 min qd or bid, total 10× as a course |
Dexamethasone ointment, salicylic acid ointment, and triamcinolone acetonide acetate ointment, slow injection of procaine 4–6 mg/kg plus vitamin C 300 mg in 300 ml saline once a day for 10–15 days as a course, warm water bath qd or 1 × 2 days (only for the control group) |
Overall clinical efficacya: T>C (χ2 = 5.796, p<0.05) |
NS |
Wang et al. [90], China; 24.7 days average, 1 year |
Oral CHM + topical APP (675) vs. topical APP (200) |
Yin Xie Ling ointment, 0.3 mm thickness, qd |
Dichlorodiethyl sulphide (1:10,000 in petroleum jelly), 0.3 mm thickness, qd |
Overall clinical efficacya: T>C (90.7>84 %, p<0.05); mean inpatient time to lesion clearance: T<C (24.7<32.5 days); follow-up relapse: T<C (13<76 %) |
'Allergic response rate' T\C (1.93/5 %) |
Trials with topical CHM as primary intervention |
Yang et al. [91], Qingdao, China; 8 weeks, NS |
Topical CHM + oral APP (96) vs. topical APP + oral APP (86) |
Liubaibaibi cataplasm: apply enough cataplasm to cover the lesions for 6 h, bid |
En Fu cream (clobestasol): bid Co-intervention: folic acid (10 mg): oral, tid; vitamin E (0.2 g): oral, tid |
Clinical efficacy based on reduction of PASI score: T>C (χ2 = 5.0, p<0.05) |
No SAE, mild itching and burning (T = 4, C = 5) |
Xu J [92], Beijing, China; 8 weeks, 3 months |
T1: topical HM + oral HM (30) vs. T2: topical HM + oral HM (30) vs. C: topical placebo + oral HM (30) |
T1: Conventional Qinbai Ruangao (ointment) T2: Fine Qinbai Ruangao (ointment) |
C: white vaseline ointment. Clean the affected skin, then apply the ointment, bid Co-intervention: Liangxue Huoxue Tang (decoction) in 400 ml decoction, oral, bid |
Clinical efficacy: T1/T2>C (p<0.05), T1 ≈ T2 (p>0.05); reduction of modified PASI scores: T1/T2>C (p<0.05), lesion area rating: T1 ≈ T2 ≈ C; single-symptom scores (erythema, scaling, infiltration, and itching): all T1/T2<C (p<0.05); single symptom time to improvement: all T1/T2<C (p<0.05) |
Slight erythema and irritation (T1 = 2, T2 = 1, C = 1) |
Zhou et al. [93], Beijing, China; 4 weeks, NS |
Topical CHM + oral CHM (51) vs. topical placebo + oral CHM (49) |
New Pulian Ointment |
Placebo ointment: mainly contained Jian qu (Massa Fermentata Medicinalis bid Co-intervention: conventional clearing heat and cooling blood decoction qd |
RER:T>C(χ2 = 13.0998, p = 0.0003); TER: T>C (χ2 = 12.7298, p = 0.0004); PASI scores: T<C (p<0.05); score of erythema, infiltration, and lesion area: all T<C (p<0.01); score of scaling: T ≈ C (p>0.05); score of itching: T<C (χ2 = 8.1145, p = 0.0044) |
AEs: none |
Zhu et al. [94], Sichuan, China; 2 weeks, NS |
Topical CHM (41) vs. topical APP (44) |
Xiaoxuanling formula bid |
Tretinoin cream (0.025 % Diwei cream: vitamin A acid cream) bid |
Clinical efficacy based on PASI: T ≈ C (χ2 = 2.125, p = 0.05) |
T: slight tingling sensation (7), C: slight burning (6) |
Song et al. [95], Beijing, China; 4 weeks, 0.5 years |
T: topical CHM + oral CHM (60) vs. C1: topical APP + oral CHM (29) vs. C2: topical placebo + oral CHM (29) |
CEBO bid |
C1 (WM): Daivonex ointment (calcipotriol) bid; C2 (placebo): vehicle of CEBO bid |
Modified PASI scores: T<C2 (p<0.01), C1<C2 (p<0.01), T<C1 (p<0.01) Clinical efficacy: T>C2 (p<0.01), C1>C2 (p<0.01), T ≈ C1 (p>0.05) Single symptom scores: T<C2 (p<0.01), C1<C2 (p<0.01) Time to symptom improvement: (1) itching: T<C1/C2 (p<0.01); (2) erythema, scaling, and induration: T/C1<C2 (p<0.01); (3) lesion area: T ≈ C1 ≈ C2 |
T: slight erythema and irritation (2), C1: erythema and lesion enlarged (2), C2: none |
Gao et al. [96], Qingdao, China; 8 weeks, NS |
Topical CHM + oral APP (192) vs. topical APP + oral APP (184) |
Liubai Baibi cream |
En Fu cream (clobestasol) bid Co-interventionsb: folic acid (10 mg): oral, tid; Vitamin E (0.2 g): oral, tid |
Clinical efficacy based on reduction of PASI score: T>C (χ2 = 36.15, p<0.01) |
No SAE, mild itching, and burning (T = 7, C = 9) |
Lu and Miao, 2004 [97], Shenyang, China; 18 days, NS |
Topical CHM (31) vs. topical APP (22) |
Queyin tincture in water with 75 % alcohol, 1000 ml, for 2 weeks, then filter and set aside Lesion on the limbs/chest– back used as target area (7.5–30 cm2) bid |
Piyanning tincture (compound fluocinonide tincture): lesion on the limbs/chest–back used as target area (7.5–30 cm2) bid |
Clinical efficacy based on reduction of symptom score: T>C (p<0.05) |
NS |
Wang et al. [98], Changsha, China; 8 weeks, 1 year |
Topical CHM (112) vs. topical APP (56) |
1# Herbal bath formula (for blood-heat syndrome) 2# Herbal bath formula (for blood-deficiency syndrome) 30 g 1#/2#: In 180–200 L water boiled for 20 min, then filter into warm liquid for bath, 20 mins, bid |
0.1 % Anthralin ointment bid (in the morning and at night) |
Global PASI: T<C (p<0.001) Clinical efficacy: T>C (χ2 = 6.25, p<0.05) Relapse comparison: T<C (χ2 = 5.50, p<0.05) |
NS |
Trials with bath CHM as primary intervention |
Shi et al. [99], Beijing, China; 56 days, NS |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (170) vs. phototherapy alone (168) |
CHM bath: 20 min, qod: NB-UVB: consistent with control intervention |
NB-UVB (310–315 nm): 0.2–0.4 J/cm2 as initial dosage, increased by 0.1 J/cm2 each time, qod |
TER based on PASI 60: TER T: 84.7 %; C: 70.2 % (p<0.01) |
Mild redness, pruritus (T: 11/170; C: 29/168); skin pigmentation in all (resolved without medical assistance within 3 months); no SAE |
Wang et al. [100], Kaifeng, China; 28 days, NS |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (50) vs. phototherapy (50); co-interventions used also |
CHM bath: 30 min, qod; NB-UVB: consistent with control intervention; urea emollient after NB-UVB, qd |
NB-UVB (310–315 nm): 0.3–0.5 J/cm2 as initial dosage, increased by 10–20 % each time, qod; urea emollient after NBUVB, qd |
TER based on PASI 60: TER T: 86.0 %; C: 72.0 % (p<0.05) |
Mild skin dryness, burning pain after NB-UVB (T: 4/50; C: 5/50); no SAE |
Wu et al. [101], Chengdu, China; 40 days, NS |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (75) vs. phototherapy (65); co-interventions used also |
Halometasone emollient for 1-week pre-trial treatment: qd; CHM bath: 15–20 min, qod; NBUVB: consistent with control intervention; urea emollient, qd |
Halometasone emollient: consistent with treatment intervention; NB-UVB (310–315 nm): 0.5–0.6 J/cm2 as initial dosage, increased by 0.1 J/cm2 each time, qod; urea emollient, qd |
TER based on PASI 60; PASI score: TER T: 78.67 %; C: 56.92 %, (χ2 = 10.54, p<0.01); PASI score T: 9.24 ± 2.17; C: 5.46 ± 1.86 |
Slight light skin dryness, burning pain after NBUVB (T: 2/75; C: 3/65); no SAE |
Lin et al. [102], Hefei, China; 49 days, NS |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (95) vs. phototherapy (90); co-interventions used also |
CHM bath: 20–30 min, three times a week; NBUVB: consistent with control intervention; Bing Huang Fu Le ointment after NB-UVB, qd |
NB-UVB (311 nm): 0.3–0.5 J/cm2 as initial dosage, increased by 0.1 J/cm2 each time, 110 s, three times a week; Bing Huang Fu Le ointment after NB-UVB, qd |
TER based on PASI 60; PASI score: TER: T: 96.7 %; C: 70 %, (χ2 = 17.69, p<0.01); PASI score T: 11.15 ± 8.11; C: 14.74 ± 9.05 |
Redness (T: 9/95; C: 22/90; χ2 = 4.44, p<0.05); pruritus (T: 11/95; C: 26/90; χ2 = 4.94, p<0.05); skin dryness (T: 15/95; C: 17/90; p>0.05); no SAE |
Wu et al. [103], Guangzhou, China; 90 days, NS |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (40) vs. phototherapy alone (39) |
CHM bath: 15–20 min, qod; NB-UVB: consistent with control intervention |
NB-UVB (311–315 nm): 0.3–0.5 J/cm2 as initial dosage, increased by 0.1 J/cm2 each time, qod |
TER based on PASI 60; PASI score: TER T: 75.00 %; C: 51.28 %,(χ2 = 4.78, p = 0.029); PASI score: T: 4.21 ± 1.22; C: 6.45 ± 2.27 |
Skin dryness, pruritus (T: 5/40; C: 5/39); skin pigmentation in all; no SAE |
Gu et al. [104], Urumqi, China; 28 days, 6 months |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (89) vs. phototherapy (96); co-interventions used also |
CHM bath: 30 min, qod; NB-UVB: consistent with control intervention; Pu Lian ointment, bid |
NB-UVB (311 nm): 0.3 J/cm2 as initial dosage, increased by 0.1 J/cm2 each time, qod; Pu Lian ointment, bid |
TER based on PASI 60; relapse rate during follow-up: TER T: 94.38 %; C: 84.38 %, (χ2 = 4.8, p<0.05); relapse rate during follow-up: T: 10.81 %; C: 30.30 % (p<0.05) |
Mild redness, pruritus, and skin dryness (T: 10/89; C: 23/96; χ2 = 5.10, p<0.05); skin pigmentation in all (resolved without medical assistance within 2 months); no SAE |
Cui et al. [105], Beijing and Anshan, China; 56 days, NS |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (62) vs. phototherapy alone (57) |
CHM bath: 20 min, qod; NB-UVB: consistent with control intervention |
NB-UVB: 50 % of MED as initial dosage, increased by 0.1 J/cm2 each time, maximum dosage 2.5 J/cm2, twice a week |
TER based on PASI 60; PASI score TER: T: 96.77 %; C: 71.93 %, (χ2 = 27.755, p<0.01); PASI score: T: 4.16 ± 7.40; C: 11.40 ± 11.64; NB-UVB average dosage: T: 9.95 ± 4.76 J/cm2; C: 12.77 ± 5.05 J/cm2 (p<0.01) |
Adverse events (redness, pruritus) rate: T: 4.84 % (3/62); C: 31.58 % (18/57) (χ2 = 119, p<0.01); no SAE |
Liu et al. [106], Shijiazhuang, China; 40 days, NS |
CHM bath plus phototherapy (40) vs. phototherapy alone (40) |
CHM bath: 30 min, qod; NB-UVB: consistent with control intervention |
NB-UVB (311–313 nm): 0.08 or 0.1 J/cm2 as initial dosage, increased by 0.01–0.03 J/cm2 each time, qod |
TER based on PASI 60 (T: 95.0 %, C: 82.5 %, p<0.01) |
NS |