J&J Withdraws Morcellators Due to Cancer 'Uncertainty'

July 31, 2014

Johnson & Johnson (J&J) announced yesterday that it is voluntarily withdrawing its laparoscopic power morcellators on a worldwide basis as the controversy escalates over the risk of the   devices spreading unsuspected malignant tumors.

Ethicon, the J&J business unit that markets the morcellators, said in a statement emailed to Medscape Medical News that the company is withdrawing the devices because "the risk-  benefit assessment associated with the use of these devices in hysterectomy and myomectomy procedures for removing fibroid tumors remains uncertain."

The move represents a stronger version of a company decision announced in late April to suspend worldwide sales of its   power morcellators, which shred tissue into smaller pieces. The decision came after the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) warned on April 17 that the devices may disperse occult cancer in the   course of fibroid removal.

A regulatory crackdown appeared imminent earlier this month when the majority of members of an FDA advisory panel   endorsed putting a boxed warning on device labels about the risk of spreading occult cancer, as well as other adverse events. At its meeting, the panel heard conflicting testimony from physicians   about the pros and cons of laparoscopic power morcellation. One physician went so far as to call it "bad medicine," while others said the surgical technique should be improved but not abandoned,   given the greater risks posed with open surgery.

In its statement today, Ethicon said that withdrawing its morcellators is not the same as recalling them, which implies a performance problem. "The product performs as intended," the company   said.

Essentially, the J&J business unit is waiting until the smoke clears on morcellation and its cancer risk before taking its next step.

"Due to this continued uncertainty, Ethicon believes that a market withdrawal of Ethicon morcellation devices is the appropriate course of action...until further medical guidelines are   established and/or new technologies are developed to mitigate the risk," the company said.


Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.