The Physician: Healthy, Wealthy, and Wise?

Carol Peckham


January 23, 2014

In This Article

What and Where Do Physicians Eat?

Which Diets Do Overweight or Obese Physicians Choose?

This year's lifestyle survey asked a key new question: "Which of the following dietary approaches most closely matches your current meal patterns?" The Table provides the options and responses.

Experts generally recommend eating 5 servings of fruits and vegetables 4 or more days per week.[7] A 2013 Gallup poll on healthy diet found that 60% of Americans claimed to adhere to such diet plans,[8] which was the same percentage cited in a 2012 Gallup poll of physicians who reported this healthy approach.[6] The latest guidelines from the American Heart Association/American College of Cardiology on cardiovascular risk recommend a diet consistent with the Mediterranean type (rich in fruit, vegetables, whole grains, fish, olive oil, lean poultry, nuts, legumes).[9,10] This approach is also supported by a recent major review.[11] In the Medscape survey, it is not surprising that physicians who treated diabetes and heart disease were most likely to choose a classic Mediterranean diet (27% of endocrinologists and 23% of cardiologists) and least likely to choose the typical American diet (17% and 23%, respectively). It is surprising, though, that equal percentages of cardiologists chose diets on opposite ends of the spectrum. General surgeons, the most overweight physicians, were the most likely to choose the typical American diet (38%) (Figures 1 and 2). The diet options that best conformed to expert recommendations on healthy amounts of fruits and vegetables included not only the Mediterranean diet but also American Heart Association, lacto-ovo vegetarian, vegan, Ornish-style, and paleo diets. (Although the Ornish diet has a strong focus on low fat[12] and the paleo on avoiding processed foods and grains,[13,14] both also stress high amounts of vegetables and fruits.)

When analyzing responses to questions about diet by self-reported weight, we found that 62% of normal to underweight physicians but only 39% of those who are overweight choose these healthy diets. Even worse, among the heavier group, 44% report that they routinely choose either meals "on-the-go" or a standard American diet (meat most days; carbs most days from white rice, potatoes, or white flour products; high fat) compared with only 28% of those with healthier weights. Although only a small percentage said they routinely had meals on-the-go, 6% of intensivists were prone to eat that way.

Surprisingly, only 16% in the obese and overweight groups are on weight-loss diets. The gluten-free diet was also an option, but this is an avoidance diet rather than one that emphasizes health, and it garnered very few responses. The verbal responses mostly reflected a mix of these diets, although a large percentage who wrote in said they had Asian-type diets.

Figure 1.

Mediterranean Diet

Figure 2.

Standard American Diet

Eating Out

The Keystone Forum on Away-From-Home Foods reported that the percentage of American food budgets spent on away-from-home foods rose from 26.3% in 1970 to 46% in 2002, and according to subsequent reports in the popular press, this percentage has not decreased since then.[15,16] The Forum also concluded that eating out more frequently is associated with obesity, higher body fat percentage, and higher BMI,[17] which has been observed in other studies as well.[18,19,20] Still, it is not certain whether eating out is related to obesity or whether only those who eat at fast-food chains are more vulnerable.[21,22] This is reflected in the Medscape survey, where almost two thirds (65%) of overweight to obese physicians say they eat out at least once a week, but so do more than half (56%) of those who are normal to underweight.

In a recent Gallup poll, 80% of Americans report eating at fast-food restaurants at least monthly, with almost half saying they eat fast food at least weekly.[23] This follows a 2006 Pew report, which found that 41% of American adults ate fast food at least once a week, suggesting an increase in this unhealthy dietary habit.[24] Regardless of weight, when physicians eat out, the majority (68%) choose mid-level local restaurants. However, not surprisingly, more of the heavier physicians say they eat at mid-level (32%) or fast-food (17%) chains than do the physicians with healthier weights (26% and 11%, respectively). There is some evidence that the nutritional quality of fast-food restaurants has increased over the past few years, but improvement is still needed.[25]


Comments on Medscape are moderated and should be professional in tone and on topic. You must declare any conflicts of interest related to your comments and responses. Please see our Commenting Guide for further information. We reserve the right to remove posts at our sole discretion.
Post as: