Food Protein-Induced Enterocolitis Syndrome

From Practice to Theory

Stefano Miceli Sopo; Monica Greco; Serena Monaco; Salvatore Tripodi; Mauro Calvani

Expert Rev Clin Immunol. 2013;9(8):707-715.

Fifth Criterion: 'A Standardized Food Challenge or Isolated Re-exposure Elicited the Typical Symptoms'

Leonard et al.^[1] also do not change anything about this criterion. Even if this standard is considered necessary for FPIES diagnosis, it is not always observed in clinical practice, as doctors are scared of its consequences since during the acute phase the child may feel very unwell. This is the reason why many allergists refuse to perform an OFC if they are aware of the occurrence of only one typical episode. Adding to all this, parents often refuse to re-expose their babies to the suspected food. Many cases of FPIES diagnosis based on a single and severe episode were even published in literature,^[3,4] but we do not agree with this attitude, as there can be a high risk of wrong diagnosis and a consequent elimination of important foods from the patient's diet. On the contrary, we believe that the best way to make a correct diagnosis is the presence in the patient's clinical history of at least two typical episodes, one of which could be a failed OFC. Unlike Powell^[2] and in agreement with Leonard et al.,^[1] we do not believe that the ingestion of culprit food must necessarily be isolated. In summary, we think that the fifth Powell^[2] and Leonard et al.^[1] criterion has to be respected. From practice to theory: Bridget performed an OFC, as she presented only one typical episode, while Ernst did not do the same, as he experienced FPIES symptoms three times.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21

Next Section

Table 1. Acute and chronic FPIES clinical manifestations.
Acute FPIES	Chronic FPIES
Important and repetitive vomiting (constant)	Regurgitation, small amounts of vomit
Lethargy (frequent)	Lethargy
Hyporeactivity (frequent)	Failure to thrive
Pallor (frequent)	Dehydration
Diarrhea (inconstant and tardive)	Diarrhea, sometimes bloody
Dehydration (rare)	Abdominal distention
Hypothermia (rare)	Hypotension (rare)

Table 2. Diagnostic criteria of FPIES.
Powell, 1986²	Leonard et al., 2012¹	Miceli Sopo et al., 2013
Less than 9 months of age at initial presentation (reaction)	Less than 9 months of age at initial diagnosis	Less than 2 years of age at first presentation (frequent feature but not mandatory)
Exposure to the incriminated food elicits repetitive vomiting and/or diarrhea within 4 h without any other cause for the symptoms	Repeated exposure to causative food elicits gastrointestinal symptoms without alternative cause	Exposure to the incriminated food elicits repetitive and important vomiting, pallor, hyporeactivity and lethargy within 2–4 h. Diarrhea may be present, much less frequently and later. The symptoms last a few hours, usually less than 6 h
Symptoms limited to the GI tract	Absence of symptoms that may suggest an IgE-mediated reaction	Absence of symptoms that may suggest an IgE-mediated reaction
Avoidance of the offending protein from the diet results in resolution of symptoms	Removal of causative food results in resolution of symptoms	Avoidance of the offending protein from the diet results in resolution of symptoms
A standardized food challenge or isolated re-exposure elicits the typical symptoms	Re-exposure or oral food challenge elicits typical symptoms within 4 h	Re-exposure or oral food challenge elicits typical symptoms within 2−4 h. Two typical episodes are needed to deliver the definitive diagnosis

Box 1. Clues in favor of a specific IgE role in food protein-induced enterocolitis syndrome pathogenesis.
There are some cases with positive specific IgEs against the culprit food, even if their levels are low. In one child,, during an episode of acute FPIES caused by rice, a plasmatic cytokinic trend similar to those of IgE-mediated allergic reactions was observed, with an increase of IL-4 and a decrease of IFN-γ [10]. The fact that symptoms arise 2 h after the ingestion of the culprit food is not a typical feature either of classical IgE-mediated forms (the reaction usually appears long before 2 h) or of classical non-IgE-mediated forms (which usually manifest long after 2 h). Few patients (with positive specific IgE research) present a shift in symptoms from those of FPIES to those of gastrointestinal anaphylaxis [11]. Regarding CM FPIES, there is a report about the capability of tolerating the culprit food if well-cooked (baked) [12].