Study Design |
Patient Characteristics |
Treatment Regimen |
Study Duration |
Outcomes |
Results |
Venlafaxine |
Open-label (n=28)[13] |
Men taking androgen deprivation therapy (18%) and women with history of breast cancer (82%); 89% ≥ age 50 yrs; 90% had > 4 hot flashes/day; 68% taking tamoxifen |
Venlafaxine 12.5 mg b.i.d. |
4 wks |
Hot flash score, number of hot flashes |
Mean changes in hot flash scores NR Mean number of hot flashes decreased by 2.3/day |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled (n=229)[14] |
History of breast cancer or fearful of getting breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (% with history of breast cancer NR); mean age NR; mean of 8 hot flashes/day; 69% taking tamoxifen or raloxifene |
Venlafaxine 37.5, 75, or 150 mg q.d. vs placebo |
4 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Median decrease in frequency of hot flashes: 19% (placebo), 30% (37.5 mg), 46% (75 mg), 58% (150 mg) Median decrease in hot flash score: 27% (placebo), 37% (37.5 mg), 61% (both 75 mg and 150 mg) |
Open-label (n=102)[15] (continuation of above study[14]) |
History of breast cancer or fearful of getting breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (% with history of breast cancer NR); mean age 53 yrs; 91% had ≥ 4 hot flashes/day; 66% taking tamoxifen or raloxifene |
Venlafaxine 37.5, 75, or 150 mg q.d. |
8 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Maintained response in initial study[14] in the 75- and 150-mg/day groups Patients previously taking placebo had a 62% mean decrease in hot flash scores Patients taking 37.5 mg/day had an additional 26% mean decrease in hot flash scores |
Double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover (n=70)[16] |
History of breast cancer; mean age 50.5 yrs(37.5 mg), 53.0 yrs (75 mg); mean of 7.46 hot flashes/day; 51% (37.5 mg), 63% (75 mg) taking tamoxifen or an aromatase inhibitor |
Venlafaxine 37.5 or 75 mg q.d. vs placebo |
12 wks (6 wks active treatment) |
24-hr sternal skin conductance, number of hot flashes, self-reported number of hot flashes |
Mean decrease in frequency from baseline: 37.5 mg/day: 22% with sternal monitoring, 42% self-reported (p<0.001); 75 mg/day: 14% with sternal monitoring, 25% self-reported (p=0.013) |
Double-blind, crossover (n=64)[17] |
History of breast cancer; 61% > age 50 yrs; mean hot flashes/day: 9.9 (clonidine), 10.9 (venlafaxine); 82% (clonidine) and 90% (venlafaxine) taking tamoxifen or aromatase inhibitor |
Venlafaxine 37.5 mg b.i.d. vs clonidine 0.075 mg b.i.d. |
8 wks (4 wks in each arm) |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Median hot flash frequency decreased by 7.6 hot flashes/day (57%) with venlafaxine and by 4.85 hot flashes/day (37%) with clonidine (p=0.025) Median hot flash scores decreased by 11.4 units/day (57%) with venlafaxine and by 8.9 units/day (39%) with by 8.9 units/day (39%) with clonidine (p=0.043) |
Randomized, controlled (n=218)[18] |
History of breast cancer or fearful of getting breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (61% history of breast cancer); mean age 55 yrs; 90% had ≥ 4 hot flashes/day; 41% taking tamoxifen or raloxifene |
Venlafaxine 37.5 mg q.d. × 1 wk then 75 mg q.d. vs MPA 400 mg i.m. × 1 |
6 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Actual changes in hot flash frequency NR Hot flash scores decreased 79% with MPA vs 55% with venlafaxine (p<0.0001) |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled (n=80)[19] |
Relatively healthy, menopausal women; mean age: 51.6 yrs (placebo), 52.7 yrs (venlafaxine); mean hot flashes/day and hot flash score NR in text (graphs provided); mean yrs since menopause: 4.0 (placebo), 4.9 (venlafaxine); surgical menopause: 22.5% (placebo), 18.9% (venlafaxine) |
Venlafaxine extended release 37.5 mg q.d. × 1 wk then 75 mg q.d vs placebo |
12 wks |
Hot flash score |
Hot flash scores decreased by 51% in venlafaxine group vs 15% in placebo group (p<0.001) at 12 wks |
Open-label (n=14)[20] |
Menopausal women with depressive disorder; mean age 45.9 yrs; mean hot flashes/day NR; mean GCS vasomotor score 1.6; mean yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR |
Venlafaxine 37.5 mg q.d. × 1 wk then 75 mg q.d. with optional dosage increase |
8 wks |
HAM-D and GCS scores |
GCS vasomotor subscores were not significantly different from baseline Vasomotor symptoms were not required for study entry |
Desvenlafaxine |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled (n=707)[21] |
Relatively healthy, menopausal women; mean age: 54 yrs (placebo), 53 yrs (all desvenlafaxine groups); mean number of moderate-to-severe hot flashes/day: 10.8 (50 mg), 10.5 (100 mg), 11.2 (150 mg), 11.1 (200 mg), 11.0 (placebo); mean yrs since surgical/natural menopause: 8/4.4 (50 mg), 10.8/4.2 (100 mg), 11.0/4.4 (150 mg), 13.1/4.9 (200 mg), 11.2/6.4 (placebo); surgical menopause: 21.3% (50 mg), 20.7% (100 mg), 22.6% (150 mg), 21.7% (200 mg), 23.4% (placebo) |
Desvenlafaxine 50, 100, 150, or 200 mg q.d. vs placebo |
52 wks |
Number of moderate-to-severe hot flashes, hot flash score |
Hot flash frequency decreased by 51-64% in all groups at wk 12; the 100- and 150-mg groups had significantly greater decreases in hot flashes/day vs placebo at wk 12: 7.23/day (p=0.005) and 6.94/day (p=0.020), respectively, vs 5.50/day Hot flash score decreased from baseline in all 5 groups at wk 12; the 100- and 200-mg groups were significantly better vs placebo in hot flash score reductions: 31% (p=0.002) and 27% (p=0.013), respectively, vs 18%; results beyond wk 12 NR |
Duloxetine |
Open-label (n=20)[22] |
Menopausal women with major depression; mean age 52.3 yrs; mean hot flashes/day NR; median GCS vasomotor score 5.0; mean yrs since menopause NR; 7% surgical menopause |
Duloxetine 30 mg q.d. × 1 wk then 60 mg q.d. × 3 wks with optional dosage increase |
8 wks |
MADRS (primary) and GCS scores |
Significant differences from baseline in total GCS score (p=0.0001) and GCS vasomotor subscore (p=0.003); actual scores NR |
Paroxetine |
Open-label (n=13)[23] |
History of breast cancer; mean age 51.6 yrs; mean hot flashes/day NR; mean hot flash severity score 3.62; 69% taking tamoxifen |
Paroxetine 10 mg q.d. × 3 days then 20 mg q.d. |
5 wks |
Hot flash score |
Significant decrease in hot flash score by 43% to 2.08 (p<0.002) |
Open-label (n=30)[24] |
History of breast cancer; 73% ≥ age 50 yrs; 74% had ≥ 5 hot flashes/day, 80% taking tamoxifen |
Paroxetine 10 mg q.d. × 1 wk then 20 mg q.d. |
5 wks |
Number of hot flashes/wk, hot flash score/wk |
Significant decrease in hot flash score by 43% to 2.08 (p<0.002) |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover (n=151)[26] |
Menopausal women with or without history of breast cancer (80% with history of breast cancer); median age 50-55 yrs across groups; mean hot flashes/day: 7.3 (paroxetine 10 mg/placebo), 6.9 (paroxetine 20 mg/placebo), 7.1 (placebo/paroxetine 10 mg), 7.8 (placebo/paroxetine 20 mg); > 60% taking tamoxifen or raloxifene |
Paroxetine 10 or 20 mg q.d. vs placebo |
8 wks (4 wks active treatment) |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Weekly hot flash frequency decreased by 67%, and hot flash score decreased by 75% compared with baseline (p values NR) |
Paroxetine CR |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled (n=165)[25] |
Menopausal women with or without history of breast cancer (7% with history of breast cancer); mean age: 53.6 yrs (12.5 mg), 55.0 yrs (25 mg), 53.6 yrs (placebo); mean hot flashes/day: 7.1 (12.5 mg), 6.4 (25 mg), 6.6 (placebo); mean yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR; use of tamoxifen and raloxifene: 2% (12.5 mg), 8.6% (25 mg), 10.8% (placebo) |
Paroxetine CR 12.5 or 25 mg q.d. vs placebo |
6 wks |
Hot flash score |
10-mg group: hot flash frequency significantly decreased by 27% (p=0.0006) and hot flash scores by 31.9% (p=0.0008) vs placebo 20-mg group: hot flash frequency significantly decreased by 25.2% (p=0.002) and hot flash scores by 28.6% (p<0.0001) vs placebo |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled (n=56)[27] |
Relatively healthy, menopausal women; mean age: 57.0 yrs (placebo), 55.6 yrs (paroxetine); mean hot flashes/day NR; median GCS vasomotor score: 4.0 (placebo), 4.5 (paroxetine); mean yrs since menopause NR; surgical menopause: 32.2% (placebo), 28.5% (paroxetine) |
Paroxetine CR 12.5 mg q.d. × 2 wk vs placebo; may increase to 25 mg q.d. if not efficacious and is well tolerated |
6 wks |
Number of hot flashes, GCS score |
Significantly decreases in hot flash scores in both 12.5-mg and 25-mg groups vs placebo (62% and 65%, respectively, vs 37%, p<0.001) |
Fluoxetine |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover (n=81)[8] |
History of breast cancer or fearful of getting breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (% history of breast cancer NR); age ≥ 50 yrs: 73% (placebo/fluoxetine), 75% (fluoxetine/placebo); mean of 7.9 hot flashes/day; taking tamoxifen: 56% (placebo/fluoxetine), 53% (fluoxetine/placebo) |
Fluoxetine 20 mg q.d. vs placebo |
8 wks (4 wks active treatment) |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Median hot flash frequency decreased by 6.2 in paroxetine group vs 2.8 in placebo group (p=0.03) GCS scores also significantly decreased (p=0.04); scores NR 63% increased paroxetine dose to 25 mg/day |
Open-label (n=12)[29] |
History of breast cancer; mean age 47.9 yrs; mean of 8.8 hot flashes/day; mean hot flash score 27.1, 66% taking tamoxifen |
Fluoxetine 10 mg q.d. |
4 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Fluoxetine was significantly better than placebo: median daily hot flashes decreased by 1.5 (19%, p=0.01), hot flash scores decreased by 3.1/day (24%, p=0.02) |
Randomized, controlled (n=120)[30] |
Relatively healthy, menopausal women; mean age: 53.1 yrs (black cohosh), 52.7 yrs (fluoxetine); mean hot flashes/day NR; mean MKI score: 25.1 (black cohosh), 25.2 (fluoxetine); mean yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR |
Fluoxetine 20 mg q.d. vs black cohosh 40 mg q.d. |
6 mo |
MKI and hot flash scores |
Hot flash frequency decreased by 36% (p=0.001) and hot flash scores decreased by 46.2% (p=0.0006) compared with baseline MKI scores were significantly better with black cohosh than fluoxetine at 3 mo (mean ± SD 13.9 ± 19.1 vs 18.5 ± 5.9, p=0.002); MKI scores at 6 mo NR Hot flash scores were reduced more with black cohosh than fluoxetine (85% vs 62%, p<0.001) |
Fluoxetine or citalopram |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled (n=150)[31] |
Relatively healthy, menopausal women; mean age 54 yrs; mean hot flashes/day and KI scores NR in text (graphs provided); mean yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR |
3 arms: fluoxetine, citalopram, placebo Fluoxetine and citalopram dosage: 10 mg q.d. × 1 mo, then 20 mg q.d. × 5 mo, then 30 mg q.d. × 3 mo |
9 mo |
KI score, number of hot flashes |
All 3 groups had significantly improved hot flash frequency and KI scores from baseline (p<0.001 for all comparisons); no significant differences were noted between groups, including comparison with placebo |
Sertraline |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover (n=62)[33] |
History of breast cancer with depression; mean age 53.9 yrs; mean of 5.8 hot flashes/day; 100% taking tamoxifen |
Sertraline 50 mg q.d. vs placebo |
12 wks (6 wks active treatment) |
Complete resolution of hot flashes in initial 6 wks (primary), hot flash score, number of hot flashes/wk |
No patient experienced complete resolution of hot flashes in initial 6 wks After initial 6-wk phase, no significant differences were noted between groups in hot flash scores or frequency After second 6-wk phase, sertraline was significantly better than placebo in improving hot flash scores (−1.7 vs 3.2, p=0.03) and number of hot flashes/wk (−0.9 vs 1.5, p=0.03) Data were analyzed as 2 different treatment periods (initial 6 wks and second 6 wks); data for treatment and placebo arms were never pooled for analysis |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover (n=97)[34] |
Relatively healthy, menopausal women; mean age 52.6 yrs, mean of 47.3 hot flashes/wk; mean yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR |
Sertraline 50 mg q.d. vs placebo |
9 wks (4 wks active treatment) |
Number of hot flashes, severity of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Weekly hot flash frequency decreased by 5 and was significantly better than placebo (p=0.002) Median hot flash scores decreased more in sertraline arm than placebo arm (48% vs 30%, p=0.001) |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, (n=99)[35] |
Relatively healthy, menopausal women; mean age: 52.6 yrs (placebo), 50.5 yrs (sertraline); mean hot flashes/day: 9.3 (placebo), 8.6 (sertraline); mean hot flash score: 18.4 (placebo), 16.4 (sertraline); mean yrs since menopause: 3.1 (placebo), 3.9 (sertraline); % surgical menopause NR |
Sertraline 50 mg q.d. × 2 wks then 100 mg q.d. 4 wks vs placebo |
6 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
No significant differences were noted between groups both in hot flash frequency and hot flash scores |
Citalopram |
Open-label (n=18)[36] |
History of breast cancer or fearful of getting breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (83% history of breast cancer); mean age NR; 72% had ≥ 4 hot flashes/day; 50% taking tamoxifen or aromatase inhibitor |
Citalopram 10 mg q.d. × 1 wk then 20 mg q.d. × 3 wks |
4 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
64% decrease in hot flash scores and 58% decrease in hot flash frequency compared with baseline |
Open-label (n=22)[37] |
History of breast cancer or fearful of getting breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (90% breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (90% history of breast cancer) and failed venlafaxine therapy for hot flashes; median age 58 yrs, 100% had ≥ 4 hot flashes/day; 65.5% taking tamoxifen or aromatase inhibitor |
Citalopram 10 mg q.d. × 1wk then 20 mg q.d. × 3 wks |
4 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Mean hot flash frequency decreased by 45% and hot flash scores decreased by 53% compared with baseline (p<0.001 for both comparisons) |
Randomized, placebo-controlled (n=100)[38] |
Relatively healthy, postmenopausal women; mean age: 53.5 yrs (citalopram), 52.5 yrs (citalopram + HT), 51.7 yrs (placebo), 53.6 yrs (placebo + HT); mean hot flashes/day NR; MKI scores NR in text (graphs provided); mean yrs since menopause: 6.9 (citalopram), 7.3 (citalopram + HT), 6.1 (placebo), 6.0 (placebo + HT); % surgical menopause: 24% (citalopram), 32% (citalopram + HT), 24% (placebo), 12% (placebo + HT) |
4 arms: citalopram, citalopram + HT, placebo, placebo + HT Citalopram dosage: 10 mg q.d. × 1 wk, then 20 mg q.d. × 3 wks; may increase to 40 mg q.d. × 4 wks if insufficient improvement |
8 wks |
MKI and hot flash scores |
Mean hot flash and MKI scores significantly improved in all 4 groups compared with baseline; however, these scores were significantly better in the citalopram and citalopram + HT groups than in the placebo or placebo + HT groups (p<0.01 and p=0.001, respectively) |
Escitalopram |
Open-label (n=32)[39] |
Menopausal women with depression; mean age: 49 yrs (HT), 50 yrs (escitalopram); mean hot flashes/day NR; median total GCS score: 26.9 (HT), 28.7 (escitalopram); yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR |
Escitalopram vs HT Escitalopram dosage: 10 mg q.d. × 4 wks; may increase to 20 mg q.d. if insufficient improvement |
8 wks |
MADRS (primary) and GCS scores |
Median total GCS score decreased significantly more with escitalopram than HT (17.8 vs 8.75, p=0.01); vasomotor subscores were significantly different between therapies |
Fluvoxamine Open-label (n=22)[40] |
Menopausal women with depression; mean age 52.9 yrs, mean hot flashes/day NR, mean SMI score 68.5, yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR |
Fluvoxamine 50 mg q.d. |
6 wks |
SRQ-D (primary) and SMI scores |
SMI scores decreased by 27% from baseline (p<0.05) |
Randomized, controlled (n=42)[41] |
Menopausal women with depression and anxiety; mean age 48 yrs, mean hot flashes/day: 6.5 (HT), 6.7 (fluvoxamine + HT); yrs since menopause and % surgical menopause NR |
Fluvoxamine 50 mg q.d. vs fluvoxamine 50 mg q.d. + HT |
8 wks |
SRQ-D score (primary), number of hot flashes |
Both treatments significantly decreased the frequency of hot flashes from baseline; however, significantly fewer hot flashes were noted in the fluvoxamine + HT group than the fluvoxamine group (0.9 vs 1.8, p=0.036) |
Mirtazapine |
Open-label (n=22)[4] |
History of breast cancer or fearful of getting breast cancer from ERT or HRT use (59% history of breast cancer); mean age 56 yrs; 82% had ≥ 4 hot flashes/day; 54% taking tamoxifen or raloxifene |
Mirtazapine 7.5 mg q.d. × 1 wk, then 15 mg q.d. × 1 wk, then 30 mg q.d. × 1 wk, then may continue at 30 mg q.d. or decrease to 15 mg q.d. × 1 wk |
4 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Median daily hot flashes decreased by 52.9% and median hot flash scores decreased by 59.5% from baseline |
Open-label (n=27)[43] |
History of breast cancer; 45% aged > 50 yrs; 75% taking tamoxifen, raloxifene, or aromatase inhibitor |
Mirtazapine 15 mg q.d. × 1 wk then 30 mg q.d. |
12 wks |
Number of hot flashes, hot flash score |
Hot flash frequency decreased by 56.5% and hot flash scores decreased by 62.2% from baseline at wk 8 (p<0.05) |
Comments